Discussion about this post

User's avatar
KJZ's avatar

Very interesting piece, but I think it finds its limits towards the end. You admit it's legitimate even as a liberal to say "You could be achieving the exact same thing with fewer resources." But doesn't this just push the disagreement back a step to what is "the exact same thing"? If my friend chooses a flight that takes 4 hours 30 minutes door to door over a train that takes 5 hours because he wants to get to his week-long vacation 30 minutes sooner, I guess a truly even-handed liberal would say "I respect that you value that extra 30 minutes at the cabin enough that you are willing to blow your carbon budget on it", but I think even within liberalism there needs to space to say, "You are being irrational, that 30 minutes doesn't matter, you could be achieving *basically* the same thing with fewer resources."

Zac Hill's avatar

Andy, this was spectacular - both in its particular application and its generalizable modality. I think liberalism is underdefended right now, and I think many attempts to defend liberalism either conflate it with status-quo institutionalism or with moralization about pluralism. What I think you’ve done instead, successfully, is dropped into a gears-level breakdown about why liberalism is the necessary design solution to i) the presence of competing moralities absent ii) an imperative to eradicate them.

38 more comments...

Ready for more?